I don’t know what I expected when I picked up The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna, but I do know I was pleasantly surprised! I thought this would just be a cute and cozy magic realism book, but this was so much more!
Off the bat, the romance was a little unexpected. Now, I know the synopsis mentions finding new love, but I honestly thought it would just be something in passing. This was nothing in passing. It was so ingrained to the story itself, and the growth of the characters, the furtherance of the general plot at large. Watching the romance unfurl slowly, tentatively, sweetly between surly Jamie and sunshiny Mika was a balm to the soul. It was organic and believable and didn’t need to focus on anything spicy or smutty, this felt deeper. That said, there was a spicy scene toward the end so if you aren’t a fan of open door romance, you may have to skip a few pages at the end.
While the romance was fantastic, it wasn’t what made this book cleave its way into my heart. It was the manner in which generational maternal, and general female relationships, were portrayed. Through Mika, and Primrose we see how generational trauma continues. How the worst of our parents shape us and the generations to come – for better or worse. With the three young wards that Mika is called in to teach, we experience the tangle of baggage that comes with one has been raised. It hit so heavy because, for whatever reason, it always seems that mother/daughter relationships are the most fraught and fragile. Too much what I could have been and what I will never be and we see this throughout the novel.
I honestly strongly recommend The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna. Mandanna flawlessly integrates a deep romance with thorough insights into female relationships and even touches upon the lasting effects of colonialism.